MGI Research

Friday, Oct 23rd

Last update02:31:08 AM GMT

MGI Analyst Blog

News and unfiltered commentary from analysts at MGI Research.

Did SAP Overpay for Ariba?

Posted by MGI Research
MGI Research
MGI Research Analyst Team
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 24 May 2012 in Cloud Computing

In a research note published last night - SAP Buys Ariba – A Fallen Angel Finds an Exit, we analyze the merits and metrics of this transaction and the impact on SAP customers, investors and competitors.

On May 22, 2012, SAP announced its intent to acquire Sunnyvale, CA-based Ariba, - a procurement software specialist. The purchase price of approximately $4.5 billion represents a premium of nearly 20 percent over Ariba’s closing price on May 21, 2012. This is an important deal that impacts SAP investors, the competitive landscape, and Ariba and SAP customers in both near and the long-term. Ariba is a one-time fallen angel whose stock price peaked above $1,012 only to crash below $6/share. For Ariba management and long-term shareholders, this is a major exit event and an unqualified success.

SAP’s intent to acquire Ariba underscores a fundamental change in the direction of SAP.  Five key questions define the analysis of this transaction:

  • Question One – Did SAP Overpay?
  • Question Two – How does this deal help SAP customers?
  • Question Three – How does this deal help SAP?
  • Question Four – What does this deal signal to SAP investors?
  • Question Five – What is the Impact on the Competitive Landscape?

This research note reviews opportunities and risks created when combining Ariba with SAP. We analyze the price paid, explore the implications for SAP and Ariba customers, and detail the impact on competitors and shareholders. The bottom-line for SAP customers and investors is not nearly as encouraging as it is for SAP competitors.

Related Recent Posts:

SAP Did not Overpay for SuccessFactors

MGI Research Tech M&A Outlook from March 2012 Bloomberg LP conference

SaaS 2012 Valuation Guide Published

Convio (CNVO) gets acquired by Blackbaud (BLKB) for $16/share

SAP Concedes - Questions Concerning SAP's bid for SuccessFactors

IBM Purchase of DemandTec Reconfirms MGI SaaS Valuation Model

© (c) 2012 MGI Research, LLC
Tags: 2011 market update public saas, 2011 saas valuation multiples, 3 factors shaping cloud, ACI Worldwide, ACIW, acquisition for saas product, acquisition multiples, acquisition sap, Actuate, ADBE, Adobe, ADSK, Advent Software, ADVS, Amdocs, amdocs saas, Andrew Dailey, ANSS, Ansys, app industry trends, application software industry trends, ARBA, Ariba, ASIA, AsiaInfo, aspen technology, Athena Health, ATHN, Autodesk, average saas revenue, average valuation for saas, AZPN, BBBB, BIRT, Blackbaud, Blackboard, BLKB, BMC, BMC Software, Bottomline Technologies, Broadvision, BSQR, BSquare, business saas software valuations, BVSN, CA, Cadence Design, CALD, Callidus Software, CDNS, CERN, Cerner, Citrix, CKSW, Clicksoftware, cloud, cloud computing, cloud computing industry analysis, cloud computing industry trends, cloud computing security incidents, cloud computing technical analysis, cloud cyber incidents, cloud industry trends, Cloud software valuation, CNQR, CNVO, collabnet, Commvault Systems, company valuation trends, compare saas multiples to tech software, Compuware, Concur, Constant Contact, Constellation Software, Convio, CPWR, CRM, CRM valuations, CSG Systems, CSGS, CSOD, CSU, CTCT, CTXS, current trends in cloud computing, current valuations of software companies, CVLT, DealerTrack, deferred revenue analysis, Deltek, DemandTec, Digimarc, DMAN, DMRC, DOX, DWRE, early stage valuation of saas companies, enterprise saas companies, Enterprise Software, enterprise software and hardware industry analysis, enterprise software pricing 2011, enterprise software public comps, enterprise software valuation, enterprise software valuations, enterprise software valuations versus saas valuations, enterprise software venture valuation, enterprise software vs saas, enterprise vs saas, enterprize software companies, EPAY, EPIC, Epicor Software, ERP valuations, erp workday company valuation, European software valuations, financial valuations,, FIRE, formula for saas valuation, Forrester, Forrester analysis of SaaS, Fortinet, FTNT, future of software, Gartner, Gartner SaaS analysis, GUID, Guidance Software, GWRE, healthcare saas valuations multiples, Healthstream HSTM, how much is my company worth?, how much is my software business worth, how to price enterprise software, how to price saas for enterprise, how to value a SaaS company, how to value a software company, how to value stock options, HR software valuations, i2 technologies erp, Igor Stenmark, IL, industry analysis, industry research cloud computing, industry revenue multiple for saas, industry trends saas 2011, INFA, Informatica, ININ, Interactive Intelligence, Intralinks, INTU, Intuit, ipo, it industry analysis, it issues smb face, it software m&a multiples, JDA Software, jdas, Kenexa, key trends in cloud computing, KNXA, LAVA, Lawson Software, Liveperson, LPSN, LWSN, M&A analysis, M&A multiples, M&A trends, Magma Design, maintenance revenue multiple, manh, manhattan associates, MDAS, MedAssets, Mediware, MEDW, MENT, Mentor Graphics, Merge Healthcare, MGI analysis, MGI efficiency, MGI Index, mgi index ranking, MGI rating, mgi report on analytics, MGI Research, mgi sap analysts, MGI scores, microsoft, Microsoft Dynamics, Microstrategy, Monotype Imaging, MRGE, msft, MSTR, multiple valuation of saas versus software, multiples software companies, multiples valuation, N, NetScout, Netsuite, Novell, NOVL, NTCT, NUAN, Nuance Communications, on-premise software, open source database market share, open source market analysis, OpenText, Openwave, OPNET, OPNT, OPWV, Oracle, Oracle acquisitions, Oracle M&A, orcl, OTEX, Parametric Tech, PDF Solutions, PDFS, Pervasive Software, PMTC, premium valuations, PRGS, price/sales valuation for software companies, pricing enterprise software, pricing multiples for saas companies, pricing salesforce, private SaaS valuations, private software transactions, PRO, Progress Software, PROJ, PROS Holdings, public saas company performance vs software, public vs private software valuations, PVSW, QLIK, Qlik Technologies, QSFT, QSII, Quality Systems, Quest Software, Radiant Systems, Radisys, RADS, recent trends in cloud computing, RedHat, Renaissance Learning, research on cloud computing, revenue multiple, RHT, RightNow, RLRN, RNOW, RSYS, saas, saas acquisition, SaaS analysis, SaaS business model analysis, saas business model for software enterprise, SaaS buyers guide, saas company valuation, saas company valuation trends, saas company valuations, SaaS comparables, saas comps list, SaaS DCF analysis, SaaS experts, SaaS growth rates, SaaS growth trends, saas healthcare software valuation, SaaS IPO, SaaS M&A targets, SaaS market capitalization, SaaS market size, saas mgi, saas multiple valuation, SaaS multiples, saas multiples valuation, saas names, SaaS profitability, SaaS rankings, SaaS research, saas revenue multiple, saas revenue multiples, saas revenue multiples 2011, SaaS software, saas valuation, saas valuation metrics, saas valuation model, saas valuation multiple, saas valuation multiples, saas valuation of enterprise software companies valuations, saas valuation precedents, saas valuation trends, saas valuations vs software, saas vs enterprise software, saas vs enterprise software company valuations, SaaS vs on-premise valuations, SABA, SABA Software, Salesforce,, SAP, SAP acquires SuccessFactors, SAP acquisition, SAP acquisitions, SAP Business ByDesign, SAP M&A, SAP purchase of Ariba, SAP SaaS product, SAP strategy, SAP vs Oracle, Scientific Learning, SCIL, SciQuest, SDBT, SFSF, short ideas in tech, smb issues software as a service, smb it issues, smb tco analysis, SmithMicro, SMSI, SNCR, SNPS, sofon, software analysis, software as a service, software as a service industry price analysis, software as a service market analysis, software as a service valuations, software business models, software company ratings, software company valuation, software company valuation multiples, software company valuation software company valuation maintenance revenue, software growth rates, software industry analysis, software industry trends in database applications, software industry valuations, software M&A, software maintenance renewals and issues with credits, software maintenance valuation, software multiples, software multiples valuations statistics, software rankings, software valuation trends, software-as-a-service, Solar Winds, Soundbite Communications, SourceFire, SPRT, SPS Commerce, SPSC, SQI, SRS Labs, SRSL, SS&C Technologies, SSNC, SuccessFactors, SuccessFactors acquisitions,, SWI, SXC Health Solutions, SXCI, Symantec, SYMC, Synchronoss, Synopsys, Taleo, Tech Industry Analysis, tech valuations, technology co valuation analysis, technology industry analysis, Telenav, teradata, tight it budgets push cloud computing, TLEO, TNAV, TRAK, TYPE, ULTI, Ultimate Software, valuation analysis, valuation based on maintenance revenue, valuation calculation of saas companies, valuation comps, valuation drivers, valuation experts, valuation methods, valuation metrics, valuation multiples, valuation of saas companies, valuation of saas companies 2011, valuation of software companies, valuation trends, valuations, valuations for software companies, valuations report on virtualization, valuations saas vs conventional software, valuing a saas business, valuing a saas company, valuing saas revenue, Vasco Data, VC software valuations, VDSI, venture capital valuations, Vital Images, vmw, VMware, VOCS, Vocus, VTAL, Wall Street analysis of SaaS, what is software maintenance revenue, what's the valuation for saas venture, Workday, XATA, XATA Corp, ZIX Corp., ZIXI